Manchester United
Luke Shaw accepts Keane’s criticism after United’s win over Chelsea
Shaw admits Keane’s criticism ‘hurts’ after United’s 2–1 win; reflects on form and role. This season
Luke Shaw acknowledged public criticism from club legend Roy Keane after Manchester United’s 2–1 win over Chelsea, admitting the comments stung but describing them as part of the game.
Keane, a seven-time Premier League champion, “has never been one to pull punches when discussing his former club, or any club for that matter.” Shaw said he “took it on the chin” as United bounced back on Saturday.
Shaw responded directly after the match, offering a measured assessment of his recent form.
“Of course it hurts. He’s got a lot of experience. He was one of the best captains ever for Man Utd. Sometimes you just have to take it on the chin. I think criticism is part of being a football player. I listen to it. But for me, I think he was right. I think that last week, I wasn’t at my level at all.
“I don’t need Roy Keane to tell me. After the game, I knew that. The most important thing is knowing how good I can be. The manager knows that. I think the managers who I played with in the past know that. I’m always in the team and I’m always playing, so there must be something that the managers believe in,” Shaw said.
Shaw has started every Premier League game so far this season as a left-sided centre back in Ruben Amorim’s 3-4-2-1 system. He benefited from a full preseason following a run of injuries that limited him to just seven league appearances and five in the Europa League in 2024–25.
United’s second victory of the 2025–26 season was hard-fought. Robert Sánchez was sent off in the fifth minute for a reckless challenge outside the box. Bruno Fernandes and Casemiro scored in the first half, but Casemiro received a second yellow and was dismissed before the break. Chelsea reduced the deficit through Trevoh Chalobah in the second half, yet United held on for their second home win of the campaign.
Manchester United travel to Brentford next weekend, then host Sunderland ahead of the October international break.
Manchester United
Manchester United’s defensive problems laid bare by brutal statistic
United’s 4-0 loss exposed a defence that has already become the worst in Europe.
Manchester United’s latest collapse offered a stark reminder of just how deep their defensive issues run. Mauricio Pochettino’s first match in the dugout finished in a 4-0 defeat to Liverpool, a result that underlined the scale of the work ahead.
United actually showed some resistance before the break, but the second half brought more punishment. Rio Ngumoha and Victor Muñoz both added to the damage, while the wider numbers made for grim reading: 28 shots conceded, nine big chances, 4.38 expected goals against and 60 touches inside United’s penalty area.
By the final whistle at Anfield, United had also reached 34 goals conceded in all competitions this season, more than any other team across Europe’s top five leagues. That figure pushed them ahead of Crystal Palace and Union Berlin, giving them the unwanted distinction of being the leakiest defence in the Premier League, La Liga, Bundesliga, Serie A or Ligue 1.
Pochettino has inherited a squad that looks badly out of balance, and defence is the most obvious weakness. The situation is made harder by the fact that no new defenders are expected until the January transfer window.
Luke Shaw was unavailable for the trip, but the rest of the back line was there. Even so, the evidence suggests the issue is bigger than selection or shape. The underlying structure is broken, and responsibility for that sits with Jason Wilcox after the summer window failed to solve the problem.
United are now expected to act in winter, with at least one left back and one centre back required. The shortlist for central defence reportedly includes Fulham’s Calvin Bassey, Everton’s Jarrad Branthwaite and Brentford’s Nathan Collins. At left back, Newcastle United’s Lewis Hall remains the main target, though a mid-season move looks unlikely. Antonee Robinson is another possibility.
The schedule offers little relief. United have nine matches across the Premier League and Champions League before they can strengthen in the market. There are winnable games on paper, including Coventry City, Nottingham Forest and Sunderland at home, plus Crystal Palace away. But their league form tells a harsher story: one domestic win, 19th place and only eight points.
Liverpool
Pochettino’s Manchester United debut ends in heavy defeat at Liverpool
Pochettino’s first Manchester United match ended 4-0 at Liverpool after an early red card.
Mauricio Pochettino’s first match in charge of Manchester United could hardly have begun worse, with the visitors reduced to 10 men early on and eventually beaten 4-0 by Liverpool on Sunday evening.
The contest turned sharply in the opening minutes. Leny Yoro was dismissed after eight minutes for bringing down Alexander Isak as he looked set to go through on goal. Liverpool made the extra man count at once, with Dominik Szoboszlai converting the resulting free kick before Florian Wirtz added a superb volley three minutes later to put the home side firmly in control inside the first 15 minutes.
From that point, United were pushed into damage limitation. Liverpool kept the pressure on and, although the chances continued to come and go, the hosts eventually added a third in the 66th minute when Bradley Barcola squared for Rio Ngumoha to finish from close range. The fourth arrived in the 82nd minute after another costly United error in the build-up, allowing Wirtz to release Víctor Muñoz, who finished powerfully.
It was another sobering afternoon for a United side that has now gone nine Premier League matches without a win and sits 19th in the table. The scale of the task facing Pochettino was evident almost immediately, with his opening game effectively decided before the match had even settled.
United’s problems began with a poor defensive sequence, as Matthijs de Ligt failed to deal with a routine lobbed pass from Ronald Araújo and left Isak free to run at goal. Yoro’s challenge followed, and although it was not especially forceful, referee Sam Barrott had little option but to show the red card.
The numerical disadvantage made the rest of the evening an exercise in survival. Liverpool were far superior throughout and could have inflicted even greater damage had they been more clinical. For United, the result underlined just how far they must go to stabilise a season that is already slipping badly.
Manchester United
Fernandes Clarifies Carrick Benching as United Turn the Page
Fernandes says Carrick’s benching was tactical, not personal, before Pochettino arrived at United.
Bruno Fernandes has insisted that his omission by Michael Carrick was not punishment for challenging the manager’s methods, but a straightforward attempt to alter the team’s direction.
The Manchester United captain was back in the side the following week, yet the episode still fuelled speculation that his relationship with Carrick had become strained. Carrick was then removed from his post only a few weeks later during the November international break.
Looking back on the period, Fernandes said his comments were not the reason for being left out. He explained that Carrick spoke to him around the Bournemouth game and made clear that the decision was tactical rather than personal.
“The manager came to speak to me after that game, or before the [Oct. 25th] Bournemouth game, to say, ‘Look, I’m not going to start you tomorrow’ and everything,” Fernandes told Sky Sports .
“‘There’s nothing to do with the words of Como, I know people will make it around that. I just want to tell you that we need to change something, I need to make a change, performances have not been great, so I just want you to know that there’s nothing to do with that.’”
Fernandes also said he went back to Carrick to check whether the situation had become awkward, but was reassured that there was no issue between them.
“I told him, ‘I think that you probably got our words in the wrong way, and you might be upset with me, and rightly so, if you got it in the way everyone is speaking about it,’” Fernandes continued. “And he said, ‘Bruno, I’m not; I just put you on the bench because I thought it was the best for the team.’”
Carrick’s exit in November opened the door for Mauricio Pochettino, a coach Fernandes had nearly joined during his time at Tottenham Hotspur.
Eight years on, Fernandes says he is now enjoying the opportunity to work under the former USMNT boss at United.
