Manchester United
Maguire Backs Amorim’s System as Manager Stands Firm
Maguire defends Amorim’s 3-4-2-1; Amorim refuses to change his system before Chelsea visit Saturday.
Harry Maguire has pushed back against the idea that Ruben Amorim’s 3-4-2-1 is the cause of Manchester United’s early-season difficulties, arguing that the responsibility lies with the players rather than the formation.
The three-at-the-back approach is not new to the Premier League; Wolverhampton Wanderers and Crystal Palace have adopted similar systems and Antonio Conte won the 2016–17 title with Chelsea in a 3-4-3. Maguire suggested the shape has become an easy target because results have not followed.
“I think the formation is an easy one to go at, because we’re playing something a little bit different to everybody else,” he told Sky Sports . “For me, it just became an easy one to go at when the results don’t work.
“The formation has been fine. Like I said, box to box we been pretty comfortable in every game. Tactically we’ve been comfortable in every game, it’s got to be down to the players. The players have got to take their moments, they’ve got to make the difference in those moments.
“I think this season, the first four games, we just haven’t done them ‘moments’ well enough. And like I said, we haven’t defended in our box well enough in the big moments. Every time the opposing team comes near the box, it ends up in the back of the net, which is something we need to work on.
“But I think the formation is just an easy one to dig out because we’ve not been winning football matches. The formation is not a set formation, everyone says ‘3’ or ‘5’ but in a lot of phases of the game, we play a back four.
“We’ve been happy since the manager has come in. It’s an easy one to dig out, but it’s down to the players to execute. And if you’re a good player, you can play in any formation.”
Amorim, meanwhile, has been unequivocal that he will not abandon his tactical approach and said he will only make changes as part of a process rather than in reaction to pressure ahead of Chelsea’s trip to Old Trafford.
“No one, not even the Pope will change [me],” Amorim stressed. “This is my job, this is my responsibility, this is my life. So, I will not change that.
“There will be an evolution, but we need to make all the good steps. If I’m a player and I have a coach that, with a lot of pressure and all around the world they are saying, ‘You need to change the system’—if I change in this moment, the players will look at me in a different way.
“When you think about the impact that any decision is going to have on the team, everything is important. So, I will say the same thing: this will have to be an evolution. I’m doing things my way. Some guys do it in a different way, but it [results] will change. I hope to have the time to change, but they will change. I’m just trying to win games, trying to see what is the best option to win the next game.
“I’m trying to get the best connections to play better and, in the end, to win points. It’s about belief, confidence, aggression, it’s everything. And sometimes, what we call luck means we will play the game with more belief. Sometimes, with us, I feel the opposite. We are playing well, but something is going to go wrong in some moments. We need to change that, but it’s just with wins.
“I can do whatever, but if you look at the goals against [Manchester] City and Fulham, all these moments can be stopped. In all these moments, I think we can do better. It’s our fault. So we work on that during the week to improve.”
Manchester United
Pochettino’s Manchester United Start Exposes Familiar Problems
Pochettino’s United debut ended in a 4-0 loss to Liverpool and deeper alarm.
Mauricio Pochettino’s first match in charge of Manchester United could hardly have gone much worse. A 4-0 defeat to Liverpool on Sunday night left his new side overwhelmed, exposed and, for long stretches, unable to compete.
The scoreline was already severe, and it could have been harsher still. Liverpool added two more goals through Rio Ngumoha and Víctor Muñoz after United had already been undone by a stream of costly errors. The result dropped United to 19th in the Premier League standings, with only one point separating them from bottom club Crystal Palace. They have now won just one of their opening 11 league matches this season.
One of the major talking points was Pochettino’s decision to start Matthijs de Ligt, even though the Dutch defender had not begun a Premier League game in over 350 days. The call backfired badly. De Ligt was directly involved in the sequence that led to Yoro’s red card when he failed to deal with a routine ball over the top and allowed Isak to run in behind him. His afternoon only worsened from there, finishing with another careless error in build-up that eventually helped Liverpool score their fourth.
After almost a year out with a back injury, De Ligt has now produced two poor starts this season, the other coming in the 4-1 defeat against Como. His confidence appears to have gone, and United’s failure to strengthen their defence in the summer remains a glaring issue.
Pochettino also opted for a 3-4-2-1 shape rather than his usual 4-2-3-1, while asking his side to press high and hold a high line with defenders lacking pace and cohesion. The midfield pairing of Youri Tielemans and Kobbie Mainoo also struggled badly without the ball, leaving Liverpool in control for large parts of the game.
Harry Maguire offered the most reliable defensive display after coming on in the 23rd minute, while Joshua Zirkzee showed some bright moments. Matheus Cunha, by contrast, was anonymous. Playing more than 80 minutes with 10 men was always going to be damaging, but the broader conclusion is unavoidable: Pochettino’s first experiment failed, and United look like a side in serious trouble.
Manchester United
Manchester United’s defensive problems laid bare by brutal statistic
United’s 4-0 loss exposed a defence that has already become the worst in Europe.
Manchester United’s latest collapse offered a stark reminder of just how deep their defensive issues run. Mauricio Pochettino’s first match in the dugout finished in a 4-0 defeat to Liverpool, a result that underlined the scale of the work ahead.
United actually showed some resistance before the break, but the second half brought more punishment. Rio Ngumoha and Victor Muñoz both added to the damage, while the wider numbers made for grim reading: 28 shots conceded, nine big chances, 4.38 expected goals against and 60 touches inside United’s penalty area.
By the final whistle at Anfield, United had also reached 34 goals conceded in all competitions this season, more than any other team across Europe’s top five leagues. That figure pushed them ahead of Crystal Palace and Union Berlin, giving them the unwanted distinction of being the leakiest defence in the Premier League, La Liga, Bundesliga, Serie A or Ligue 1.
Pochettino has inherited a squad that looks badly out of balance, and defence is the most obvious weakness. The situation is made harder by the fact that no new defenders are expected until the January transfer window.
Luke Shaw was unavailable for the trip, but the rest of the back line was there. Even so, the evidence suggests the issue is bigger than selection or shape. The underlying structure is broken, and responsibility for that sits with Jason Wilcox after the summer window failed to solve the problem.
United are now expected to act in winter, with at least one left back and one centre back required. The shortlist for central defence reportedly includes Fulham’s Calvin Bassey, Everton’s Jarrad Branthwaite and Brentford’s Nathan Collins. At left back, Newcastle United’s Lewis Hall remains the main target, though a mid-season move looks unlikely. Antonee Robinson is another possibility.
The schedule offers little relief. United have nine matches across the Premier League and Champions League before they can strengthen in the market. There are winnable games on paper, including Coventry City, Nottingham Forest and Sunderland at home, plus Crystal Palace away. But their league form tells a harsher story: one domestic win, 19th place and only eight points.
Liverpool
Pochettino’s Manchester United debut ends in heavy defeat at Liverpool
Pochettino’s first Manchester United match ended 4-0 at Liverpool after an early red card.
Mauricio Pochettino’s first match in charge of Manchester United could hardly have begun worse, with the visitors reduced to 10 men early on and eventually beaten 4-0 by Liverpool on Sunday evening.
The contest turned sharply in the opening minutes. Leny Yoro was dismissed after eight minutes for bringing down Alexander Isak as he looked set to go through on goal. Liverpool made the extra man count at once, with Dominik Szoboszlai converting the resulting free kick before Florian Wirtz added a superb volley three minutes later to put the home side firmly in control inside the first 15 minutes.
From that point, United were pushed into damage limitation. Liverpool kept the pressure on and, although the chances continued to come and go, the hosts eventually added a third in the 66th minute when Bradley Barcola squared for Rio Ngumoha to finish from close range. The fourth arrived in the 82nd minute after another costly United error in the build-up, allowing Wirtz to release Víctor Muñoz, who finished powerfully.
It was another sobering afternoon for a United side that has now gone nine Premier League matches without a win and sits 19th in the table. The scale of the task facing Pochettino was evident almost immediately, with his opening game effectively decided before the match had even settled.
United’s problems began with a poor defensive sequence, as Matthijs de Ligt failed to deal with a routine lobbed pass from Ronald Araújo and left Isak free to run at goal. Yoro’s challenge followed, and although it was not especially forceful, referee Sam Barrott had little option but to show the red card.
The numerical disadvantage made the rest of the evening an exercise in survival. Liverpool were far superior throughout and could have inflicted even greater damage had they been more clinical. For United, the result underlined just how far they must go to stabilise a season that is already slipping badly.
