Manchester United’s latest home defeat to Bournemouth should, on paper, have produced anger aimed squarely at Michael Carrick. Instead, parts of the Old Trafford crowd chose a different response after watching their side lose for an eighth straight match.

As the manager was still on the touchline, supporters sang: “It’s Carrick, you know,” to the tune of Pilot’s 1974 song Magic. They followed it with: “It’s hard to believe it’s not Scholes.”

But the mood shifted sharply once Carrick headed down the tunnel. Boos rang out, quickly joined by explicit chants that underlined the depth of frustration around the club.

The reaction reflected a wider anger that has existed for years. Manchester United fans have been protesting against the ownership since the Glazer family took control on June 28, 2005. Kobbie Mainoo, by then, was only two months old.

Supporters have long objected not simply to the presence of the Glazers, but to the way the takeover was financed. The debt-laden structure left the club carrying heavy interest payments, while the owners remained protected in the boardroom. For many fans, the message has stayed the same: “Sell United and f— off home.”

That anger briefly eased when Sir Jim Ratcliffe and INEOS arrived with a takeover offer in December 2023. Ratcliffe took control of day-to-day sporting operations, initially buying 25% of the shares before increasing that to 28.9%. Yet the Glazers remain involved, and the frustration has only deepened as results have failed to improve.

INEOS has made key appointments, including Omar Berrada as CEO and Jason Wilcox as technical director, but the club is now approaching a fourth permanent manager since their arrival less than three years ago. The transfer windows have also fallen short of expectations, leaving the squad short of what is needed on the pitch.

Carrick can only influence preparation and tactics. Once the match begins, responsibility shifts to the players, and that is where supporters have seen the biggest failings. Bruno Fernandes, benched for the Bournemouth game after speaking out against Carrick’s tactics, is among the senior names who have disappointed this season.

The team have looked sluggish, often outran, and short of the effort supporters demand. That is why a banner calling for the standards of Eric Cantona, Roy Keane and Bryan Robson was brought back out against Bournemouth.

Carrick is not beyond criticism, but many fans believe the deeper problem lies above him, not on the touchline.

Michael Carrick’s start has become harder to defend after Manchester United’s latest setback at Old Trafford, with the manager now matching a sequence the club had not seen since the early part of the century.

United have never gone nine matches without a win since 2000, but Carrick has now equalled the eight-game stretch previously recorded by Louis van Gaal between November and December 2015. That run remains a familiar reference point, not least because Van Gaal kept his job despite it.

The Dutchman’s sequence ended with a 0-0 draw against Chelsea, a result that appeared to buy him more time. He then opened 2016 with a 2-1 victory over Swansea City, a result that helped him see out the season. Whether Carrick receives the same patience is now the central question.

United’s next fixture is another meeting with Chelsea, and it arrives at a moment when the club need something to shift quickly. The Blues’ performance against Tottenham Hotspur on Saturday was described as awful, which at least leaves open the possibility of a much-needed response from Carrick’s side.

The wider picture is bleak. As the analysis notes, there is effectively little United can do to change matters other than dismiss the manager. Results are demanded immediately, yet the feeling around the club is that Carrick has too few allies in senior positions if performances continue at this level.

The problems extend beyond the dugout. The board are under scrutiny, but any real reset would take time. The ownership need to settle on a direction, the recruitment team need to prioritise properly and the squad needs to be cleared of a toxic culture that is dragging everything down. Those are not fixes that happen overnight.

Pressure is also building around Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox, but replacing two of the club’s most powerful figures would be another long and complicated process. United do not have the luxury of waiting, with Chelsea, Roma, Aston Villa, Liverpool, Sporting CP and Brentford all next on the schedule. On current form, the winless run could easily grow even longer.

The Premier League never takes long to turn against a manager, and with no dismissal yet this season, the pressure is already building around a handful of dugouts.

The opening weeks have been difficult for several head coaches, whose teams have struggled to deliver after the September-October international break. That has sharpened attention on four managers who appear most vulnerable if results do not improve quickly.

Michael Carrick was handed a permanent role after engineering Manchester United’s revival as interim boss last season, earning significant backing from supporters and decision-makers alike. Yet the first full campaign has brought a hard reset. United have looked far less convincing, even if emphatic home wins over Ipswich Town and Sabah FK have offered some cover. Heavy defeats to Hull City, Manchester City, Brighton & Hove Albion and Atlético Madrid have told a different story, and a 3-0 home loss to Bournemouth has intensified talk around his future. Recruitment frustrations have only added to the strain, while supporters made their feelings clear by chanting Carrick’s name before quickly turning to boos after the defeat.

Oliver Glasner left Crystal Palace after delivering FA Cup, Community Shield and Conference League success, and Pierre Sage now inherits the challenge of matching that standard. Sage’s record with Lens in France was highly impressive, but Palace’s early-season form has been poor enough to raise concern. Wins over Fulham and Forest are their only league victories so far, and conceding 19 goals in eight games has left them among the division’s weakest defences. Reports of a dressing-room issue and tension with the board have done little to calm the situation.

Álvaro Arbeloa’s appointment at Fulham was always a bold move. Marco Silva had regularly exceeded expectations, and Arbeloa’s short, strange and unsuccessful spell as Real Madrid manager did little to ease doubts. After three straight defeats, including concerning defensive displays against Chelsea and Crystal Palace, Fulham steadied themselves with draws against Liverpool and Manchester United before slipping again against Ipswich Town. Back-to-back wins over Hull City and Coventry have improved the mood, but the pressure remains.

Frank Lampard’s work at Coventry City has restored his reputation and returned the club to the Premier League for the first time in 25 years. Even so, six defeats in eight matches and only six goals scored have created a difficult backdrop, despite recent wins over Nottingham Forest and Newcastle United.