Carabao Cup
Guardiola details five VAR grievances after Semenyo goal is ruled out
Guardiola warned VAR errors have accumulated across five incidents, from FA Cup final, Newcastle tie.
Pep Guardiola used the aftermath of Tuesday’s Carabao Cup semifinal victory over Newcastle United to air a long-standing grievance with VAR decisions that, in his view, have accumulated across several matches. Rayan Cherki would belatedly establish a 2–0 lead for the visitors to take into the second leg of the tie at the Etihad Stadium next month, giving Guardiola the platform to set out his complaints.
City’s manager returned repeatedly to the same themes during a six-minute critique of refereeing and VAR. He defended his players and stressed resilience: “We know how it works and that will make us stronger,” he told Sky Sports. “I’ve said it many times to the team, it is always about that. It’s in that situation how we react and how we compete.”
Guardiola singled out the disallowed second-half goal by Antoine Semenyo, which was awarded on the pitch but overturned by VAR Stuart Attwell on offside lines involving Haaland. The decision required referee Chris Kavanagh to review a pitch-side image after VAR judged Haaland to have been actively interfering with Malick Thiaw’s attempt to clear the effort. Guardiola asked why the decision had to be referred: “Four officials and VAR were not able to take the decision, they had to go to the referee,” he said, later adding with sarcasm: “Today, the line was perfect. Millimetres.”
He also recycled incidents from earlier in the season on Tyneside and the Premier League meeting with Newcastle, describing those moments as missed punishments, including what he called “two insane penalties.” “In the league game here, 60 minutes and 20 minutes, take a look,” Guardiola said. “I don’t understand why in the Premier League game with [Fabian] Schär on Phil [Foden] why VAR didn’t say anything. Then the penalty with [Jérémy] Doku and Thiaw.”
Guardiola referenced last season’s FA Cup final as part of his wider critique: “Did you review the FA Cup final last season? When [Dean] Henderson touched the ball outside the box. Did I say anything?” He urged those responsible for officiating to answer for decisions: “Ask them. Who is the boss of the referees? Ask him [Howard Webb]. It’s the semifinals. We play for a lot to reach the finals. It will make us stronger.”
The reaction to VAR decisions has also drawn outside comment, with ITV pundit Ian Wright calling one contentious FA Cup ruling “absolutely pathetic.”
Carabao Cup
Chelsea await scan results after Martínez is stretchered off against Everton
Chelsea are waiting on scan results after Emiliano Martínez was stretchered off with a head injury against Everton.
Chelsea are facing an anxious wait over Emiliano Martínez after the goalkeeper was forced off against Everton with a head injury.
The incident prompted immediate concern. Branthwaite was sat up shortly after, but medical staff rushed on to attend to Chelsea’s stopper, who was visibly in distress on the pitch. After a prolonged spell of treatment, Martínez was taken away on a stretcher and went straight to hospital for scans. As he was leaving the field, he appeared to be moving his arms.
Mike Penders replaced him and became the youngest goalkeeper in Chelsea’s Premier League history. The 21-year-old’s introduction is expected to be the first of many over the coming years, with club officials viewing him as a long-term option.
Chelsea will not be able to set any proper return timeline until the formal diagnosis is known, although it would be a major surprise to see Martínez back before the end of the month at the very least. If the injury proves more serious, his absence could easily stretch beyond that.
The club are now waiting on the scan results to understand the full picture. That uncertainty could also affect Xabi Alonso’s plans for a busy run of fixtures. Tottenham Hotspur visit next weekend, followed by a Carabao Cup tie with Liverpool, a game for which Martínez may have been rested anyway. The month then closes with a meeting with Manchester United before Chelsea travel to Sunderland ahead of the November international break.
Any extended lay-off would hand Penders a significant run in the side. The towering 21-year-old impressed while on loan with Strasbourg last season, and Chelsea opted to keep him at the club this year rather than send him out again. He has already started both of Chelsea’s Carabao Cup matches, and after his debut, a 2–0 win over Luton Town in the second round, Alonso said the Belgian will soon have a major role to play.
Carabao Cup
Carrick urges caution as Gabriel row grows around United future
Carrick says Gabriel’s welfare comes first as United weigh a 15-year-old’s uncertain future.
Michael Carrick has stressed that the priority in the JJ Gabriel situation must be the teenager’s welfare, wellbeing and exposure, as the debate around the 15-year-old intensifies.
The latest twist is believed to stem from Gabriel’s frustration over limited first-team involvement. He made an unofficial appearance from the bench in preseason, but that remains his only senior involvement so far. The forward is regarded as a major talent, while attention has also turned to his father, Joe O’Cearuill, after allegations of difficult behaviour resurfaced this week. One claim is that Gabriel’s name was changed to make him more marketable.
When it emerged that Gabriel wanted to leave Manchester United, it was suggested Carrick had intended to give him a record-breaking debut against Brighton & Hove Albion in the Carabao Cup. That did not materialise, and it would have been difficult for the manager to do so anyway after United let a 2-0 lead slip and were forced into a frantic search for an equaliser.
Carrick had already spoken to the media before the game, so his post-match comments at Old Trafford were the first chance to address the sudden attention around Gabriel. He avoided discussing the player’s quality or whether his future may lie elsewhere, instead focusing on the fact that the boy’s image has now spread widely.
“I think we’ve got to be really careful of the whole situation,” Carrick, whose own son, Jacey, is in the United academy and a year older than Gabriel.
“He’s a young boy, and the biggest thing for me, and for the club, is his welfare, wellbeing and exposure. I think all of us have to be really conscious of that in this situation.”
The safeguarding concerns are real. Gabriel requires separate changing facilities from senior players, and his age places him among only three players to have featured in 34 Premier League seasons at 15.
United can still delay matters by refusing to cancel his registration, though his academy deal runs until the end of the season. From next season, the usual route would be a first-year scholar place, with professional terms available when he turns 17 in the second year. A move abroad could come sooner, however, because Irish and Cypriot heritage may allow him access to EU passports. That gives Real Madrid a notable advantage, should he head to Spain when he turns 16 next month.
Arsenal
Merino Sees Yamal-Like Traits in Dowman After Ipswich Cup Display
Merino compared Max Dowman to Lamine Yamal after the teenager impressed in Arsenal’s cup win.
Mikel Merino has drawn a notable comparison between Arsenal teenager Max Dowman and Barcelona’s Lamine Yamal after the 16-year-old’s eye-catching showing in Tuesday’s Carabao Cup win over Ipswich Town.
Merino, who knows Yamal well from international duty with Spain, said Dowman shares more than just talent with the Barcelona forward. In his view, the pair are alike in how they handle pressure and attention.
“There are some similarities in terms of their character,” Merino reflected. “They don’t care about the spotlight. They thrive when pressure is at the highest. They are always up for the challenge and they are not shy at all, even facing the biggest names in the game.
“[Dowman] is an unbelievable talent. We knew it, but every time he goes on the pitch and plays against grown men he makes the difference. He is a big talent and we have to take care of him.
“We have to keep pushing him. He needs to keep learning—eyes and ears open always. There is still big room for improvement in a lot of areas and he knows that. So we are going to be by his side trying to get him to his best level.
“It is a thin line. It is very difficult to have equilibrium sometimes with him, because obviously you want him to shine and show everyone the talent that he has. But you have to sometimes remind them that they are human beings and they are part of a bigger squad and team.
“The good thing with these kind of players—Lamine and Max—is that they are special talents, but at the same time they are very humble. They are always keen to learn and listen to the veterans. That is priceless.”
Dowman, who turns 17 on Dec. 31, has now delivered three goals and one assist in 14 senior appearances for Mikel Arteta’s side.
Arteta, though, stressed that progress must be handled carefully. He said the Premier League presents a different challenge from other leagues and that Dowman’s development needs patience and the right conditions.
“Everything is possible,” Arteta said when asked if Dowman could become a first-team regular. “The probability probably is extremely low, because you don’t see the players with the capacity to handle just the physicality of the game.
“Not only that, but the demands that you have to put your bodies through in the week to be able to be in a good condition to compete, the amount of information, the challenges that you have to face.
“But he’s doing it, and he’s doing it really well every time he’s got a chance. What we have to do is look after him. He’s 16 years old, you don’t see that in this league.
“In other leagues in Europe, that’s a totally different context. But in this league, with the demands that the league, the players and everything puts on you, we really need to make sure every time we throw him in, he’s in the right context with the right preparation, and that’s what we are trying to do.”
