Man Utd
Keane Condemns United’s Boardroom Influence and Questions Recruitment of Managers
Keane says Ferguson and Gill’s continued presence creates a ‘bad smell’ over United’s succession. etc.
Roy Keane launched a pointed criticism of Manchester United’s leadership this week, arguing that the continued presence of former figures has hampered successive managers. The former club captain singled out Sir Alex Ferguson and David Gill as lingering influences and suggested their roles on the club board remain a problem.
“You see who’s making the decisions at Manchester United ,” Keane tailed off during a rant on Sky Sports this week, “you still have Ferguson and David Gill hanging on like a bad smell.” Ferguson and Gill remain non-executive directors and regular figures at Old Trafford, a reality Keane said affects those appointed after Ferguson left the dugout.
The club’s history was used as context. United hold a joint-record 20 top-flight titles but only three managers are responsible for those successes. Ernest Mangnall led in the first decade of the 20th century, Sir Matt Busby oversaw the club’s peak across the 1950s and 1960s, and Ferguson later dominated for decades. Busby, like Ferguson, did not fully relinquish influence when stepping away. After appointing Wilf McGuinness as his successor in 1969, Busby kept the title of manager while McGuinness was designated “chief coach.”
“Not everyone, sadly, would play for Wilf,” United’s David Sadler would later reflect. “The side as a whole did not give 100% effort for him. It was as simple as that.” Busby returned for an ultimately doomed second spell, a fate Ferguson has so far avoided.
Keane also directed his ire at the club’s recent recruitment and decision-making, criticising minority co-owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe and director Jason Wilcox for their roles during Ruben Amorim’s “disastrous 14-month reign.” “What happens in these job interviews? I’m intrigued,” Keane asked, his beady eyes dancing around the Sky Sports studio. “Why do they keep giving certain people a job? What happens in the interview that they sit there and go, and 12, 14 months later, ‘he’s not the guy for us.’
“Almost forget the CV,” he added. “You need something on your CV, of course, that you’ve won a trophy or managed a long time. But you’ve got to look somebody in the eye and go, ‘Are you the man to get us places?’” Keane dismissed the idea of Darren Fletcher as the permanent manager and expressed a preference for Eddie Howe.
Man Utd
De Zerbi Linked to Manchester United as Spurs Continue Talks
De Zerbi is reportedly open to Manchester United while Spurs continue talks amid ongoing instability
Reports suggest Roberto De Zerbi is interested in the Manchester United job even as Tottenham Hotspur continue to hold talks with him. The situation has added pressure to an unsettled managerial picture at both clubs, where interim managers Michael Carrick and Igor Tudor are fighting for their futures.
Tudor is reported to be at risk of being sacked after just three games, with Spurs sitting one point clear of the relegation zone. While Carrick is believed to have done enough to remain in the running at United, the potential availability of De Zerbi will complicate summer planning for both sides.
Talks between Spurs and De Zerbi have been held, but the Italian is expected to hold out for more appealing offers this summer. His high octane soccer earned admirers during spells with Sassuolo and Shakhtar Donetsk between 2018 and 2022, and it was at Brighton & Hove Albion that he established himself among the world’s elite.
It is widely accepted that De Zerbi overachieved with the Seagulls and he spoke with a handful of big names, including both Spurs and United, during the summer of 2024 before taking his talents to Marseille. The French side finished second in Ligue 1 during his first season in charge, playing a possession-heavy brand of soccer that was both aesthetically pleasing and effective on the field.
There is a sense that his approach would suit a team built to be favorites every week, but his style of management remains a concern for some suitors. De Zerbi is a fiery character who is not afraid to raise his voice and challenge anybody in his path, be that his own players or those above him in the hierarchy. His departure from Brighton stemmed from public disappointment towards his limited impact in the club’s transfer dealings, and that could be a major issue for both United and Spurs as they lean into the modern approach of appointing “head coaches” to lead the team and hand the transfer business to a recruitment department.
United, having shaken off the cobwebs of the Erik ten Hag and Ruben Amorim eras, have enjoyed enough on-field success to remind the world of their pedigree and reputation as the biggest brand in English soccer. With the promise of a hefty transfer budget this summer, the allure of the Red Devils is clear. Spurs, meanwhile, face the added complication that they cannot even offer assurances of Premier League status next season after two seasons at the wrong end of the standings, leaving them with an uphill battle to retain their place among England’s ‘Big Six.’
Man Utd
United place $50m-plus valuation on Onana as loan and wages cloud a permanent exit
United demand more than $50m for Onana; loan move, wages and 2028 contract complicate sale. overall.
Manchester United have placed a valuation in excess of $50 million on goalkeeper André Onana, according to Trabzonspor vice president Zeyyat Kafkas. Onana was quickly moved out on loan to Türkiye after signing for United from Inter in 2023, and the presence of Lammens in the United goal has intensified scrutiny of the Cameroon international’s form.
Kafkas says United remain intent on recouping a fee close to what they originally paid. “The price offered by Manchester United for André Onana’s purchase was in the €45-50 million ($52-58 million) range, and our President sincerely informed the club about the realities of Trabzonspor,” said Kafkas .
The numbers underline the difficulty of finding a buyer. United paid $57 million to sign Onana and are now attempting to recover a similar sum almost three years on. The goalkeeper will turn 30 in April and his contract runs until 2028, factors that complicate any permanent deal.
Kafkas also suggested the loan environment has not necessarily altered the player’s own priorities. “I don’t think this information affected Onana at all. Because Onana’s intention is to continue playing for a club in Europe if not in England. His family also thinks that way. The President wanted to explain the realities of Trabzonspor. However, if the circumstances change, the situation will change”
Beyond transfer fee expectations, United face the practical problem of Onana’s wages, listed at $164,000-per-week. That salary makes a permanent move harder to engineer and increases the likelihood that United will pursue further loans if they cannot find a club willing to meet the financial terms. In short, the club’s valuation, the player’s contract length and his weekly pay together create a narrow path for a straight sale.
Man City
United and City Both Monitor Felix Nmecha Amid Midfield Planning
United and City are linked to Felix Nmecha as both clubs weigh midfield rebuilding and renewal ahead
Manchester United and Manchester City have both been linked to Borussia Dortmund midfielder Felix Nmecha as each evaluates midfield options ahead of a period of change.
Nmecha, 25, is under contract in Germany until 2028, but his long-term future at Dortmund is described as uncertain. Clubs across Europe have taken note of a player who has enjoyed a career resurgence in recent seasons.
An English-educated talent, Nmecha joined City’s academy in 2007 and spent 14 years on the books at the Etihad. He made three senior appearances for Manchester City and provided an assist in five minutes of Champions League action. He left City on a free transfer to join Wolfsburg in 2021 and moved to Dortmund two years later.
At City he was primarily an attacking player, operating behind the striker and on the left wing. In Germany he has been converted into a more all-action midfielder, often deployed deeper in a midfield pivot or as a box-to-box presence. That tactical change produced some of the best performances of his career. Standing at 6’3, Nmecha combines physicality with a broad on-ball skillset, and his earlier attacking training remains evident alongside developed defensive discipline. Former Dortmund boss Nuri Şahin described the German international as a “dream” because of his versatility.
United view a versatile midfielder as a priority as they prepare to bid farewell to Casemiro and contemplate broader rebuild plans that could see Manuel Ugarte moved on and leave Kobbie Mainoo as the only natural midfielder in the squad. The profile of a player like Nmecha would give the next manager, whether Michael Carrick or somebody else, tactical options during reconstruction.
City are not in the same immediate need but Pep Guardiola accepts the need to rejuvenate a squad that has fallen short in the title race. With doubts over the futures of Mateo Kovačić, Bernardo Silva and Rodri, they may seek new faces. Some inside City will be familiar with Nmecha and may be regretting the decision not to extend his contract five years ago.
Both clubs are also linked to other targets. Nottingham Forest’s Elliot Anderson sits high on both shortlists with a reported £100 million ($133.5 million) price tag. Crystal Palace’s Adam Wharton and Brighton & Hove Albion’s Carlos Baleba are also under consideration.
