Manchester United
Five left-back options Manchester United could weigh up as Shaw’s future comes into focus
Manchester United face a left-back decision, with Luke Shaw’s future uncertain and several options under review.
Manchester United’s rebuild is still being shaped by the fallout from a dismal 2024-25 season, one that ended with defeat to Tottenham Hotspur in the Europa League final. After that setback, the club moved to refresh midfield, with Michael Carrick steering them to third place and back into the Champions League after replacing Ruben Amorim at the start of the year.
Even so, questions remain over whether the squad has been fully strengthened for the demands ahead. United made no late-summer addition at left back, leaving an obvious area of concern unresolved. Luke Shaw is now 31 and into the final year of his contract, and while he enjoyed a surprising injury-free campaign in 2025-26, the club cannot assume that run will continue through the added workload of European football.
The current alternatives do not offer the level of assurance United need, especially with possession-based structure so dependent on the left side functioning properly. A winter move would therefore make sense, whether for immediate cover or a longer-term successor.
Alejandro Balde is the most eye-catching name on the list. He was once viewed as Jordi Alba’s natural heir at Barcelona and excelled during the club’s La Liga-winning 2022-23 season, producing six assists in 33 matches. Injury and a strained relationship with Hansi Flick have complicated matters since then, and with Xavi Espart emerging, a move next year appears plausible. He would be a statement signing, although his reduction in status under Flick and his seven Spain caps suggest caution is warranted.
Rayan Aït-Nouri was also assessed in the summer and, according to BBC Sport, United could have signed him if they had chosen to do so. The Algerian offers strong technique in possession, though the club was not persuaded at the time.
A short-term fix is also possible, and United have tried that route before with Sergio Reguilón. If the focus is on the future, Joaquin Seys of Club Brugge stands out. The 21-year-old has eight Belgium caps, was included in Rudi Garcia’s World Cup squad, and impressed against France’s Ousmane Dembélé.
Destiny Udogie remains a major talent, but injuries are a clear concern. Lewis Hall would be ideal, yet his Newcastle United contract extension makes a move unlikely unless an extreme fee is paid. David Raum is another name in circulation and, at 28, he could offer more than a stopgap solution.
Manchester United
Carrick’s United position said to be safe despite looming Spurs test
United’s manager is under scrutiny, but reports say there is no appetite for change at Old Trafford.
There is said to be no immediate danger to Michael Carrick’s role at Manchester United, even if the side return from the extended September-October international break with a disappointing result.
Carrick’s first 17 matches in charge last season brought in more points than Arsenal collected across the same stretch, and he will believe United remain close to the level he expects. Two individual lapses have already cost the club five points, while another match was shaped by an objectively shocking refereeing mistake. Even so, United have generally moved the ball into the right areas and are matching Arsenal in the attacking third.
The Daily Mail reports that there is “no appetite for change” from the club’s hierarchy. The same reporting also draws a contrast with Ruben Amorim, who was overseeing gradual improvement after an extremely poor 2024-25 season before undermining himself by voicing his frustrations publicly last January.
That means the focus is on results rather than panic. Even if the Spurs fixture does not end in victory, the expectation is that the club would not “hit the panic button” over Carrick. Players were also said at the end of September to still back and support him.
Tottenham should provide a favourable matchup for United at this stage. They are bottom after failing to win any of their opening five Premier League matches and taking only two points. United are currently the division’s joint-sixth highest scorers, while Spurs have the second weakest attack, with only two goals and blanks in four matches.
The challenge for United is what follows. Between the end of the international window and the next one in mid-November, they play eight times across two competitions in four weeks. Leeds United away on Oct. 18 looks difficult, especially with Champions League trips to Atlético Madrid and Como either side of it. Bournemouth at home comes next, before Chelsea away, then home games against Roma and an improving Aston Villa.
Bayern Munich
Gabriel’s Bayern Move Hinges on Youth Transfer Terms and Salary Demands
Bayern’s pursuit of JJ Gabriel is complicated by passport rules, salary demands and playing time.
JJ Gabriel’s anticipated chance to become the first 15-year-old to appear in a competitive match for Manchester United passed last month, after he asked for his registration to be cancelled the day before Michael Carrick planned to use him in the Carabao Cup.
That request left United unable to prevent an almost immediate move abroad, though FIFA rules still place major limits on transfers involving players under 18. An exception exists for European Union citizens moving to another member state from the age of 16, and Gabriel is understood to have Irish and Cypriot passports through his family, despite being born in the United Kingdom.
Reports in Germany say he intends to secure a Cypriot passport in order to make a European move possible. Bayern Munich are now strongly involved, with the same report stating that Gabriel’s representatives have already met officials from the Bundesliga champions. The Times also says contact between the two sides had taken place as early as May.
Other major clubs have been linked as well. Barcelona publicly played down their interest last month, when sporting director Deco said: “We are not interested in any player in his situation.” Even so, Gabriel is believed to have been training in the Castelldefels suburb while the situation developed. Real Madrid and Paris Saint-Germain have also been mentioned, while Borussia Dortmund, RB Leipzig and Bayer Leverkusen are said to have cooled their interest.
The case is drawing comparisons with the Martin Ødegaard move of 2015, although that route had a wider field of options across Europe. Gabriel’s situation appears more complicated, not least because of his contractual expectations.
Sky in Germany reports that the “financial demands are considered a major hurdle” for Bayern. Although only a nominal compensation fee would be required to take his registration from Manchester United, salary and signing fees are reported to stand in the way. The Times says a “seven-figure” salary is not something Bayern are prepared to accept, with the club instead hoping that “development and future game time” will prove persuasive.
There is precedent in Munich for young players being trusted early. Lennart Karl made his first-team debut in June 2025 at the age of 17, while Jamal Musiala joined from Chelsea’s academy in 2019 at 16 and featured for the senior side 11 months later, after turning 17.
For Gabriel, patience may be essential. He, or more likely his family, are reported to have asked for a minimum of 20 minutes in pre-agreed first-team matches against Sabah, Brighton and Bournemouth during September and October. He was denied the Sabah opportunity because his name was not included in the club’s Champions League squad sent to UEFA, which required List A status because of his age.
Manchester United
JJ Gabriel’s United frustration deepens as exit becomes possible
Gabriel’s United dispute escalates as broken promises and his 16th birthday open the door to a move.
JJ Gabriel’s future at Manchester United has moved sharply toward a departure after a dispute over playing-time demands reportedly went unanswered by Michael Carrick.
According to the draft, those managing the teenager asked for a minimum of 20 minutes in three specific matches: the Champions League opener against Sabah FK, the Carabao Cup home tie against Brighton & Hove Albion, and the forthcoming Premier League meeting with Bournemouth at Old Trafford. Carrick did not appear willing to accept those conditions.
Gabriel was left out of the first-team squad for the European match and instead featured for the Azerbaijan side’s U-19 on the same day. Before United had even lost to Brighton, reports had already begun to circulate that the youngster was considering a rapid exit.
If Carrick had selected the then-15-year-old, Gabriel would have become the youngest player in Manchester United’s first-team history, overtaking the record held by David Gaskell since 1956. While the modern game has increasingly opened the door to very young players, it would still have represented a significant call.
The situation has now shifted further in Gabriel’s favour. His representatives are said to believe that “promises” have been “broken,” and with his 16th birthday on Oct. 6, a new stage has begun in the breakdown of the relationship.
That date matters because Gabriel can now take immediate action. Thanks to his European passport, the son of a former Republic of Ireland international is able to move to another club in the European Union after turning 16. For United, what began as a dispute over minutes has developed into a transfer issue with major consequences.
