Manchester City
Scholes Rejects Rooney’s View On A Possible Title Reallocation
Scholes and Rooney disagree on a retroactive title, with City’s appeal keeping the issue unresolved.
Paul Scholes has taken a sharply different line from Wayne Rooney over the idea of a retrospective Premier League title being handed out if Manchester City are punished over financial breaches. The former Manchester United midfielder made clear that he would not turn down a medal, even if the circumstances were far from ideal.
City have been found to have misreported revenues by more than $1.2 billion (£900 million) over the nine seasons from 2009-10 to 2017-18. Within that stretch, the club collected three league crowns, including the 2011-12 title that was secured on the final kick of the season and denied to a Manchester United side featuring both Rooney and Scholes.
Rooney has already said he “wouldn’t feel comfortable” accepting a medal for that campaign. He also argued, “I don’t think we deserve it. We didn’t do enough that season to win the league,” setting out why he would not want the title awarded after the fact.
Scholes responded with a much firmer position on social media. “Keep hearing ex-teammates saying they want trophies taking off them but they don’t want their medals…” Scholes wrote on social media, “f— that I’m a greedy b—— I want my medal.”
The debate comes against the backdrop of City’s guilty verdict, which remains subject to appeal. The finding was made by an independent judicial commission after two years of deliberation, and the club have said they will explore “all other legal avenues” available, including a further challenge to the Premier League or even involving the High Court of England and Wales.
For now, any possible sanction is still unresolved. But if the Premier League eventually moves to strip titles, the competition would have the authority to do so, including the possibility of redistributing medals. Even so, the first reaction reported was that clubs had “little appetite” for titles being removed, let alone reassigned, given the scale of time covered by the investigation.
Fulham
Manchester City and Fulham meet with different pressures on each side
City need a response, but Fulham arrive organised, unbeaten in four, and improving under Arbeloa.
Manchester City return to Premier League action looking to halt a three-match domestic slide, with the break arriving at an opportune moment for the sky-blue half of Manchester. Their recent run has prompted concern about how exposed they have been in defensive transition, and the need for greater security in midfield has become clear.
Fulham arrive at Etihad Stadium in steadier form. Unbeaten in four, they have moved on from a poor opening spell that left them at the foot of the table. They now sit 15th with 10 points from as many games, though the wider table remains tightly compressed in the middle.
The visitors have begun to look more coherent under Álvaro Arbeloa, who was heavily doubted on arrival. Their improvement has been built on balance, possession and the influence of Alex Iwobi, alongside the creativity of No. 10 Josh King. Recent wins over Coventry City and Ipswich Town were narrow but controlled, and they followed those with 1–1 draws at Aston Villa and against Newcastle United.
City, by contrast, lost three successive Premier League matches before the break, even if a 3–2 Champions League victory over RB Leipzig came in the middle of that slump. Maresca has urged calm and has been given time to reset, but the challenge remains the same: his team must become less vulnerable to the counterattack.
Fulham’s recent numbers suggest they are capable of making this uncomfortable. Just six goals have been scored in their last four league matches, with only two conceded, a reflection of the control they have established. City will need patience if they are to rediscover winning form.
The head-to-head record offers little encouragement for the visitors. Manchester City have won the last 20 meetings, while Fulham have not taken points off them since September 2011 and last beat them in 2009.
Manchester City
What the reported Apollo collapse could mean for Manchester City’s transfer plans
Apollo’s reported collapse leaves Manchester City facing fresh uncertainty over funding and transfers.
Manchester City’s financial outlook has reportedly taken a significant hit after a proposed $2 billion loan from Apollo Global Management was “scrapped” following the club’s guilty verdict in September over more than 100 breaches of the Premier League’s financial rules.
City have continued to insist on their innocence and have repeatedly pointed to “a comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence.” That material, which is believed to include documents and bank statements, is central to the club’s appeal and underpins the confidence inside the organisation. Outside the club, however, the response has not been nearly as supportive.
According to the Financial Times, Apollo had been preparing to inject $2 billion into the City Football Group, with the agreement understood to be in the “final stages.” The report says the deal collapsed after the guilty finding, even though City’s appeal remains ongoing.
The timing matters. Khaldoon Al Mubarak had only recently claimed that City Football Group and its 11 clubs were worth at least $10 billion, yet the loss of such a large external investment will still be felt across the wider operation.
The reported Apollo package was intended to “refinance existing credit facilities” and provide “extra liquidity”, a phrase that in practical terms points to more flexibility for daily running costs, including money that can be used for potential transfers.
City’s ownership has also put fresh equity into the structure. Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan was found to have injected £100 million ($131.5 million) into City Football Group through Newton Investment and Development at the end of October. It is not clear whether that move was a direct reaction to the lost Apollo funding, though that is how it has been framed.
Even so, the amount is far smaller than the sum Apollo had been expected to provide. The Financial Times points to rising “uncertainty” around the club’s financial future as the Premier League case continues.
Barcelona
Balde’s Situation Could Trigger Wider Winter Moves in Europe
Balde could move in January, and Barcelona’s decision may influence several European transfer plans.
Barcelona’s stance on Alejandro Balde may shape more than one transfer story this winter. The left back has been drifting toward an exit since last summer, and January now appears to offer the first realistic chance for a move away from his boyhood club.
Hansi Flick made his view plain in August when he said Balde was not “100% here” during a summer dominated by links with Manchester United. Even after repeated public declarations of loyalty, the defender never won back full trust. By mid-October, he had managed only one appearance for the defending Spanish champions, and his route back into the side looks increasingly blocked. Flick’s latest criticism was pointed: “[Balde] did not have the confidence he usually needs to play his game, nor the conviction to play as the team wants, pressing high.”
The Athletic report that Barcelona remain open to selling Balde once the winter window opens. He has played just 124 minutes this season, and as another La Masia graduate, any transfer fee would count as pure profit. For a club with well-known cash flow issues, especially after spending around €180 million ($198 million) last summer, that matters. The report also says Barcelona need departures if they want to pursue “significant arrivals” in January.
That departure could fund their main winter objective, a centre back, with a left-footed option wanted to eventually replace Iñigo Martínez. The belief is that Barcelona will not win the Champions League until Pau Cubarsí has a proper partner in central defence. A veteran addition would also help steady Flick’s high line.
If Balde leaves and a centre back arrives, the defence would change significantly. Gerard Martín could move back to left back, João Cancelo could shift right, and Flick would gain balance on both flanks once Jules Koundé and Xavi Espart return. Eric García is another option, which would also ease Frenkie de Jong out of emergency defensive work.
United remain a possible destination. Their need at left back is obvious after missing out last summer and living with Luke Shaw’s injury problems, while Diogo Dalot has struggled on the left. Under Mauricio Pochettino, they are expected to target the position again, and Balde could be available at a lower price. A deal could even open the door to Lisandro Martínez, whose difficult season and expiring contract may tempt United to sell before May.
There is also a Manchester City angle. The Athletic say Joško Gvardiol was Barcelona’s top defensive target last summer, but his new contract ties him to the Etihad Stadium until 2032.
