Manchester United failed in its bid to overturn the red card shown to Lisandro Martínez in the Premier League defeat to Leeds United. The club lodged an appeal against the dismissal found on VAR review, but the FA’s regulatory commission has confirmed the appeal was unsuccessful and Martínez will serve the three-match suspension originally imposed.

After the game, Michael Carrick was blunt in his assessment of the decision. “That decision was one of the worst I’ve ever seen,” Carrick fumed after the game. “[Calvert-Lewin] can throw his arms in Licha’s face—and then he’s sent off. Shocking. I don’t even know what it looks like. It’s not a pull, it’s not a tug, it’s not aggressive. He touches [the hair] and he gets sent off. We have got to be careful where the game is going. It is a shocking decision, absolutely shocking.” Carrick later reiterated his view but declined to expand: “It’s obvious how I felt after the game, and I still feel that way now. I don’t want to go into it now. It is what it is. We have to accept it and move on.”

The club secretary’s letter, dated two days after the match, “set out in detail” why United believed the dismissal was wrongful and that the standard punishment would be “clearly excessive.” United included three videos with the appeal: one of the full incident between Calvert-Lewin and Martínez, one showing contact made on Leny Yoro during the same match, and footage of a February hair-pulling incident involving Kenny Tete for which a sending off did not follow.

The presiding commission, made up of former referee Steve Bennett, former Premier League champion Stuart Ripley and ex-defender Francis Benali, found unanimously that there was no “obvious error” by the match officials. The judgement stated: “The pulling of a person’s hair can be interpreted to fall outside the normal constituent elements of a challenge in football and can therefore fall into the category of violent conduct. The commission did not feel that it could be said with any confidence that the force exerted by [Lisandro Martínez] on [Dominic Calvert-Lewin’s] hair/scalp was negligible.” The panel said Martínez “grasped” the hair and Calvert-Lewin’s reaction “suggested that he had felt a certain amount of force exerted upon his hair/scalp.” It concluded “it was not outside the parameters of reasonableness for the Referee to have interpreted the VAR footage in the way that he did and he could not, therefore, be said to have made an obvious error.”

The commission added that although hair pulling is low on the violent conduct scale it “ought not to be tolerated” and “should be discouraged through consistent punishment.” Martínez has served the first match of the ban and will miss the Premier League games with Brentford (April 27) and Liverpool (May 3); he will be eligible to return at Sunderland on May 9. The suspension might have been more disastrous had events unfolded slightly differently.

Jadon Sancho has indicated an openness to a third spell at Borussia Dortmund once his Manchester United contract expires this summer. Sky Sport Germany reports Sancho has “communicated his willingness” to return to the club where he enjoyed his most productive years and where, on a short-term loan, he helped Dortmund reach the Champions League final in 2024.

Dortmund had shown interest last summer but ultimately judged the move too costly. Sancho instead moved on from United, spending 2024–25 on loan at Chelsea before joining Aston Villa, and this season he has mainly been used as a backup option.

Sancho’s best period remains his first Dortmund spell, aged 17 to 21, when he emerged as a potent threat from both flanks. The compiled season record in the original report underlines that output across his early Dortmund seasons and subsequent spells (including detailed goals and assists totals from 2017–18 through the ongoing 2025–26 season at Aston Villa).

According to the Sky Germany piece, talks have included “specific financial details” and Sancho has expressed a preference for Dortmund ahead of a “multitude” of alternatives. Manager Niko Kovač is reportedly supportive, but the decision will rest with managing director Lars Ricken and sporting director Ole Book.

Staying at Aston Villa remains a possibility. When asked in February, Unai Emery said: “Hopefully he can help us by increasing his qualities in our structure like he is doing,” Emery said at the time. “He will need another contract, and maybe it could be here. If he plays his best football, we will want him. But other teams could also be involved in the interest for him.” Any Villa continuation would depend on contract terms and how well Sancho fits the club’s structure.

Other potential destinations mentioned include Turkish sides such as Galatasaray or Fenerbahçe, Napoli and AC Milan, as well as a more unlikely Watford homecoming. The report notes the risks and rewards of those options and concludes Sancho, still only 26, needs a clear reset to revive his career.

Manchester United are said to be assessing Tottenham Hotspur centre back Micky van de Ven as they look to strengthen their defence ahead of the summer window.

Since Michael Carrick took charge in mid-January, United have been focused on Premier League fixtures after exiting both domestic cups prematurely. The run of positive results has removed any hope of a lighter schedule next season, making depth across the back four a priority for the club.

The report indicates United want a left-footed centre back to help ease the burden on 19-year-old Ayden Heaven. Lisandro Martínez remains the in-house option but has battled injuries over the last two seasons and his contract runs until the summer of 2027. Injuries have also plagued Matthijs de Ligt at times, Harry Maguire is on the wrong side of 30, and pairing inexperienced talents such as Heaven and Leny Yoro to lead a return to the Champions League may be too much to ask.

Van de Ven’s season has been difficult, as it has for many at Tottenham, but his Premier League experience keeps him on United’s radar. Durability is a clear strength: the Dutchman led Spurs’ outfield players in appearances and minutes this season and reached 40 games across all competitions for the first time in his career.

At his best, Van de Ven offers notable pace, tenacity defending in space, and competence on the ball. He is able to progress play as a ball-carrier or pick passes from deep, and he has contributed offensively with seven goals this season.

Bringing Van de Ven to Old Trafford will not be straightforward. United face competition from other major clubs that have been linked with the defender. Liverpool have been mentioned previously, Chelsea have been linked amid defensive concerns, and Barcelona are expected to be active in the centre back market, with Van de Ven floated as an option if their pursuit of Alessandro Bastoni does not succeed.