Man City
Man City Player Ratings After 2–0 Derby Defeat at Old Trafford
City lost 2-0 at Old Trafford; makeshift defence and blunt attack leave Premier title hopes in doubt
Manchester City were beaten 2–0 on derby day as Michael Carrick outwitted Pep Guardiola in his return to management at Old Trafford. City controlled possession but lacked cutting edge, while United were lively on the break and struck twice in quick succession to seal the win. The result leaves City winless in four league outings.
Guardiola admitted unease before the match, and his makeshift backline looked unsettled early on. Gianluigi Donnarumma produced a series of important saves to keep the score level until United found their rhythm. A double change at half-time introduced Nico O’Reilly and Rayan Cherki, but City could not alter the game’s momentum. Erling Haaland was withdrawn with ten minutes remaining as United closed out a memorable victory.
Player ratings (out of 10)
- GK: Gianluigi Donnarumma — 6.7: Eventually bypassed, but Donnarumma made a string of excellent saves to keep the game at 0–0.
- RB: Rico Lewis — 6.5: Operated in midfield for the most part, but was pretty ineffective. Booked in the second half.
- CB: Abdukodir Khusanov — 7.0: Some of his recovery defending was superb, but Khusanov failed to inspire calm into this City defence.
- CB: Max Alleyne — 6.4: The youngster struggled to settle into the contest, especially with the ball at his feet, and he was withdrawn at half-time.
- LB: Nathan Aké — 6.4: A messy showing was epitomised by his work late on against Amad Diallo, who came ever so close to adding a third for the hosts.
- DM: Rodri — 7.4: It’s been an injury-hit campaign so far for Rodri, and the midfielder who stepped out at Old Trafford looked like a shell of the Ballon d’Or-winning superstar from two seasons ago.
- RM: Antoine Semenyo — 7.0: The January arrival’s quick start to life in Manchester was tamed by City’s fiercest rivals. Semenyo offered a threat throughout but wasn’t able to service those in the box.
- CM: Bernardo Silva — 6.2: His efforts to calm down proceedings did work early on, but Bernardo was often outmuscled, and he struggled to have any impact in the half-spaces.
- CM: Phil Foden — 6.4: Loves this fixture but was smothered at Old Trafford. Foden wasn’t given any room to breathe between the lines, and Guardiola turned to Rayan Cherki for the second half.
- LM: Jérémy Doku — 6.6: City’s liveliest player early, as he so often is, but Doku, despite playing against a booked Diogo Dalot for most of it, didn’t take over the contest as he teased to do.
- ST: Erling Haaland — 5.9: His quiet run of form continued across town. Haaland had just one sight of goal, which the sticky and rugged Lisandro Martínez blocked.
Substitutes
- Rayan Cherki (46’ for Foden) — 6.1
- Nico O’Reilly (46’ for Alleyne) — 6.1
- Rayan Aït-Nouri (80’ for Doku) — 5.7
- Tijjani Reijnders (80’ for Bernardo) — 6.4
- Divine Mukasa (80’ for Haaland) — 5.8
Subs not used: James Trafford (GK), Marcus Betinelli (GK), Stephen Mfuni, Ryan McAidoo.
Man Utd (4-2-4) Starting XI: Senne Lammens; Diogo Dalot, Harry Maguire, Lisandro Martínez, Luke Shaw; Casemiro, Kobbie Mainoo; Amad, Bruno Fernandes, Bruno Fernandes, Patrick Dorgu.
United’s opener came when Bryan Mbeumo combined with Fernandes to hand the hosts a deserved lead. The second followed when Matheus Cunha crossed for Patrick Dorgu, arriving late to finish off the post and make it 2–0. City had moments from set-pieces and good saves from Donnarumma, but their inability to turn possession into clear chances defined the afternoon.
Analytics & Stats
Premier League after 10 games: the questions that still shape the season
After 10 games, the Premier League has clearer patterns, but several major questions remain unanswered.
Ten matches into the 2026/27 Premier League season, the broad lines of the campaign are beginning to emerge. Yet with domestic football returning after the November international break, there is still no shortage of unanswered questions across the division.
At the top, Mikel Arteta is handling the kind of dilemma managers usually welcome. Ezri Konsa is in form, William Saliba is back, and the decision between them comes as key fixtures against Manchester City, Brentford, Spurs and Manchester United move into view. Konsa offers strength in duels, while Saliba brings the option of a higher line.
Aston Villa’s six-match unbeaten league run has kept them moving, but it has not been fully convincing. Unai Emery’s side have too often been drawn into frantic, open games and have not controlled them well enough. Their numbers reflect that, with Villa 15th for average possession and third for times dispossessed.
Bournemouth continue to stand out. Only Paris Saint-Germain and Real Madrid have also won their last eight matches across Europe’s big five leagues. Marco Rose’s side are Opta’s favourites for the Europa League and have not allowed European commitments to disrupt their domestic form. Evanilson, Marcus Tavernier and Rayan are operating as a dangerous front three, with Eli Junior Kroupi set to return to the mix.
Brentford are sharing goals, but Thiago is not reproducing the level he reached last season, despite getting into dangerous positions. Brighton, meanwhile, are making a more serious case by the week. They are the only side to beat Arsenal this season, they are the league’s top scorers and they are doing it with confidence and verve.
Elsewhere, Chelsea still need to find the right place for Estêvão, Coventry need points rather than encouragement, Palace are adjusting to Thomas Frank, Everton are stretched by a 21-man squad, Fulham still need a finisher, Hull remain limited, Ipswich keep making errors, Leeds need more from Wilson, Liverpool’s midfield is unsettled, and City’s three straight defeats have raised difficult questions. Newcastle, Forest, Sunderland and Spurs also carry significant concerns into the next phase of the season.
Arsenal
Gameweek 9 verdicts: Chelsea edge United, Arsenal stun Liverpool
A full set of Gameweek 9 predictions, including Chelsea vs Man Utd and Liverpool vs Arsenal.
Gameweek 9 brings a stacked Premier League schedule, with several meetings that carry clear weight in the early-season picture. The most eye-catching fixtures are Chelsea against Manchester United at Stamford Bridge and Liverpool’s home clash with Arsenal, while there are also plenty of tight contests elsewhere across the division.
At Stamford Bridge, Chelsea are tipped to come through 2-1 against a Manchester United side under pressure after back-to-back three-goal defeats to Como and Bournemouth. Michael Carrick remains in charge for the trip to west London after talks with Bruno Fernandes and the rest of the squad, but this feels like a critical test. Chelsea have their own issues, yet home advantage and the absence of João Pedro could still matter in a narrow contest.
Bournemouth’s strong run is expected to continue with a 2-1 win over Leeds United. The Cherries have produced a striking sequence of results across multiple competitions, and with Rayan, Marcus Tavernier and Evanilson supported by Eli Junior Kroupi’s return, they look well placed to extend that momentum.
Other calls point to draws for Brentford against Nottingham Forest and Newcastle United against Everton, while Coventry and Sunderland are forecast to cancel each other out. Hull are backed to edge Ipswich 1-0, and Manchester City are favoured to beat Brighton 3-2 in what could be the weekend’s most open game.
Tottenham are projected to keep improving with a 2-0 win over Crystal Palace, while Aston Villa are expected to defeat Fulham 3-0 after their recent uptick in form. The standout result, though, is at Anfield, where Arsenal are predicted to win 2-1 after Liverpool’s recent consistency meets a team looking to respond after a cup setback. The final matchup, Newcastle versus Everton, is also forecast to finish level.
Man City
Howard Backs Sullivan to Progress at Man City Despite Club Uncertainty
Tim Howard says Cavan Sullivan can still thrive at Man City despite the club’s legal uncertainty.
Tim Howard believes Cavan Sullivan will continue to develop at Man City regardless of the uncertainty surrounding the club’s legal situation.
City are facing the prospect of major punishment after being found guilty of breaching Premier League financial regulations over nearly a decade, from 2009 to 2018. The case centres on “sham” contracts and “misstated accounts” that are said to have reduced costs by £900 million ($1.2 billion).
Even so, Howard is adamant the situation will not derail Sullivan’s rise. The USMNT goalkeeper and Premier League broadcast analyst has watched the teenager move quickly through the game, and he sees no reason that momentum should slow down now.
Sullivan signed his first professional contract with the Union at 14 in May 2024. That deal included an agreement to move to Man City. Two months later, he made history by becoming the youngest player in MLS history. This season, he has continued to produce at a high level, recording seven goals and 14 assists in 20 regular season starts.
Howard made his case on his podcast with Landon Donovan, Unfiltered Soccer. “They’ve bought a lot of players, given the financial situation, but they also know how to produce players,” Howard said. “They know how to get the best out of players. Their players don’t fail a lot.”
He highlighted Oscar Bobb, who spent three years developing in the blue side of Manchester before joining Fulham in January on a five-and-a-half year deal worth £27 million ($36 million). Bobb has since become a regular starter.
Howard also referenced Cole Palmer, who rose through Man City’s youth ranks before moving to Chelsea in 2023 on a seven-year deal reportedly worth £42.5 million ($56.8 million). Palmer has since become the face of the Blues.
“Their players don’t fail, so he is not going to fail there because there is uncertainty,” Howard reiterated.
City could still face a points deduction severe enough to push them into the relegation zone and down to the Championship. An expulsion from the Premier League could also lead to the EFL accepting them into the Championship. Howard’s view is that, whatever happens next, Sullivan should still benefit from the move.
