Manchester United
Counting the Cost: Manchester United’s Most Expensive Transfer Misses
A concise review of Manchester United’s costliest transfer mistakes and the financial toll. 2016-24.
In the post-Sir Alex Ferguson era Manchester United have repeatedly invested heavily to arrest a slide in fortunes. The club’s willingness to spend has delivered occasional success, but a string of high-profile signings failed to justify their price tags and left the club with substantial losses.
Eric Bailly arrived from Villarreal in 2016 and initially looked a shrewd acquisition, appearing 11 times during United’s Europa League campaign that season. Injuries curtailed his impact thereafter; he never featured more than 13 times in a single Premier League season after 2016–17. Bailly spent 2022–23 on loan at Marseille before leaving for Beşiktaş as a free agent in 2023, leaving a reported £30 million hole on the books.
Donny van de Beek arrived amid acclaim in 2020 but struggled to adapt to English football. Even the return of Erik ten Hag, his former Ajax coach, could not restore his form and he moved to Girona for a small fee in 2024.
Aaron Wan-Bissaka made 130 Premier League appearances across five years. The right back’s one-on-one defending was often excellent, but his overall game was criticised for limited involvement and occasional positional lapses. His transfer, including add-ons, approached £50 million.
Juan Mata was signed midway through the 2013–14 campaign and remained until 2022, departing on a free. He made 285 appearances, helped United to FA Cup and Europa League triumphs and became a fan favourite, representing one of the more positive outcomes among costly acquisitions.
Fred joined from Shakhtar Donetsk for £47 million. He had notable moments but required particular team profiles to thrive and was sold to Fenerbahçe in 2023.
Nemanja Matić reunited with José Mourinho in 2017 and spent five years at Old Trafford. “I arrived at United with the anger to win trophies like I had at Chelsea, but step by step I started to feel that trophies were not the focus. Maybe I’m not right, but that was my feeling inside,” Matić would later comment. His time ended without silverware.
Raphaël Varane arrived in 2021 with a stellar Madrid reputation but fitness problems limited his influence. Anthony Martial showed flashes, scoring 17 Premier League goals in 2019–20, yet left for AEK Athens on a free in 2024 after a decline. Manchester United paid EIGHTY TWO MILLION POUNDS to sign Antony from Ajax in 2022; early goals against Arsenal, Manchester City and Everton failed to secure a lasting return on that outlay and he later moved to Real Betis.
These cases underline how transfer fees alone have not guaranteed on-field longevity or value for Manchester United.
Manchester United
VAR ruled ‘inconclusive evidence’ after Šeško goal stood in Manchester United v Liverpool
Premier League: VAR said ‘no conclusive evidence’ Šeško handled ball; Darren England saw no issue. .
The Premier League issued an explanation after Benjamin Šeško’s goal for Manchester United against Liverpool was allowed to stand, citing a lack of definitive camera evidence. Bruno Fernandes’s header was diverted awkwardly by Liverpool’s third-choice custodian and fell on to Šeško’s body. Enhanced replay suggested the ball may also have skimmed the striker’s fingers.
On-pitch referee Darren England saw no issue with the finish and video assistant referee Stuart Attwell did not recommend a review on the touchline. As the Premier League would subsequently explain on their official Match Centre X account, “The referee’s call of goal was checked and confirmed by VAR—with it deemed there was no conclusive evidence that Šeško handled the ball before scoring.”
The matter was treated as one of evidence rather than intent. The FA’s Law 12 is clear that it is a handball offence if a player “scores in the opponents’ goal directly from their hand/arm, even if accidental.” In situations where the scorer is the suspected offender, the VAR process must identify a clear and conclusive angle to overturn the on-field decision. In this case officials concluded no such angle existed.
Reaction online was immediate. Blown-up images that appeared to show Šeško’s left ring finger make contact prompted calls for the goal to be disallowed. “That definitely looked like it hit Sesko’s left hand and got pushed more towards goal” reflected a commonly held view among commentators. Former Manchester United centre back Rio Ferdinand compared the moment to Diego Maradona’s “hand of god” goal, while Arne Slot pleaded for a handball from the Liverpool dugout and club icon Sir Kenny Dalglish tapped his arm in frustration from the Old Trafford stands. Even some Manchester United supporters accepted the ball may have touched Šeško’s hand. “Sesko aka hand of god! Love to see it” was among the fan responses.
With the VAR process concluded, the decision to allow the goal rested on the absence of conclusive footage rather than a judgment of intent.
Analytics & Stats
How Bruno Fernandes can rewrite two Premier League assist records against Liverpool
Fernandes can break two Premier League assist records: season assists (19) and set-piece assists…
Michael Carrick’s tactical change has given Bruno Fernandes room to operate in the right-side pocket behind the front line, and the results are clear. Carrick restored United’s skipper to the No. 10 role after a period in Ruben Amorim’s two-man midfield, and Fernandes says the move has altered his positioning. “I float a lot in that zone there now with Michael,” Fernandes reflected in an interview with Opta. “He doesn’t want me to just be stuck in the middle, so often asks me to find that pocket [of space].”
That positional freedom has put Fernandes on the cusp of two Premier League landmarks with four matches left in the season. He has 19 assists in 2025–26, level with Mesut Özil on the season charts and one behind the all-time single-season mark of 20 set by Thierry Henry and matched by Kevin De Bruyne in 2019–20. No player in the 34-year history of the Premier League has provided more than 20 assists in a single campaign, and Sunday’s derby with Liverpool presents a high-profile chance to close that gap.
Fernandes showed the shift in focus at Brentford, taking no shots as he concentrated on creating. Eventually, Benjamin Šeško finished one of the five chances Fernandes created, taking the skipper to 19 assists and a single assist behind the record.
If Matheus Cunha recovers from a slight hip issue, he is the likeliest direct beneficiary. As Opta note, Cunha has received 19 open-play chances from Fernandes this season—the most chances any player has been provided by a single teammate in the current Premier League campaign.
There is also a set-piece subplot. United’s No. 8 has set the former Real Madrid man up for six Premier League goals this season—another division high—five of which have come from set pieces. Fernandes sits on 10 set-piece assists, one shy of Steven Gerrard’s top-flight record of 11. The midfielder has worked on dead balls and admits the demands have changed: “I will tell you that five years ago, I would go to take a corner and just put the ball into the middle of the box and let’s see if someone gets it,” he revealed. “And nowadays I have to hit a spot, so sometimes it’s even harder to get an assist from a set piece than it actually is in open play.”
Arsenal
FPL Gameweek 35: Priority Picks and Value Options
GW35 FPL essentials: Raya, Darlow, Bruno, Haaland and budget defenders to boost your squad this wk.
With four gameweeks left, Gameweek 35 demands careful moves. Managers still chasing mini-league gains should prioritise reliable returns and inexpensive enablers that free funds for captains in the final stretch.
Goalkeepers: David Raya (£6.0m) remains the standout option among keepers after a 10-point haul last weekend and offers value alongside Arsenal’s defence. Fulham have blanked in four of their last six league games, making a home clean sheet plausible. At the other end of the budget spectrum, Karl Darlow (£3.9m) has accrued 24 points across his last five games and faces relegated Burnley at home, serving as a low-cost enabler. For managers planning ahead to double Gameweek 36, Dean Henderson (£5.1m) is an alternative given Crystal Palace’s two fixtures next round, despite a tricky away match with Bournemouth this Sunday.
Defenders: Gabriel (£7.2m) is a must, while Nico O’Reilly (£5.1m) has become increasingly attractive for managers preparing for City’s double in the next round; he has returned 27 points from his past three fixtures and faces low-scoring Everton away on Monday. Crystal Palace options include Jaydee Canvot (£4.5m) and Chris Richards (£4.4m) as budget routes into their backline, and Daniel Muñoz (£5.8m) offers more attacking upside after scoring in the defeat at Liverpool. Leeds defensive targets such as James Justin (£3.9m), Jayden Bogle (£4.4m) and Pascal Struijk (£4.3m) are also useful given a favourable fixture.
Midfielders: Bruno Fernandes (£10.4m) stands alone as the essential midfield pick; he is chasing the Premier League assist record for a single season and has delivered returns in each of his past seven matches, even ahead of Manchester United’s home game with Liverpool. Other options highlighted are Eberechi Eze (£7.2m), who made an impact after being brought off the bench in Europe, Rayan Cherki (£6.5m) with 23 points across his last three matches, Ismaïla Sarr (£6.3m) ahead of a double, Noah Okafor (£5.6m) despite a slight injury concern, and Enzo Fernández (£6.5m) under Calum McFarlane.
Forwards: Erling Haaland (£14.5m) is essential following recent goalscoring exploits. Support options include Dominic Calvert-Lewin (£5.7m), who could benefit from Burnley’s struggles after Scott Parker’s dismissal, and Jarrod Bowen (£7.8m), who has produced 24 points across his past two home games for West Ham ahead of a trip to Brentford.
-
Analytics & Stats2 months agoOpta Supercomputer: Tight Premier League Relegation Picture After Tottenham Defeat
-
Analytics & Stats2 months agoOpta Supercomputer Lays Out 2025–26 Premier League Forecast as Arsenal Lead the Way
-
Chelsea1 month agoEverton Weighs Legal Action over Premier League Ruling on Chelsea
