Manchester United
Interim Heat: The Carrick Debate and United’s Managerial Dilemma
Neville wants a Tuchel or Ancelotti; Keane opposes Carrick; Rooney sees clear potential. A firm note
Manchester United’s 3–2 win over Arsenal has reawakened a familiar debate about long-term leadership at the club. Gary Neville warned against rushing the decision and urged United to seek a successor “in the mould of either Carlo Ancelotti or Thomas Tuchel” when Michael Carrick leaves at the end of the season.
Neville cautioned that emotion has too often driven appointments. “Manchester United have acted emotionally a number of times in the last 12 years,” he said. “I honestly could not be happier with the last two weeks. The familiarity in what I’m watching feels like I’m watching my team play again properly.
“They played properly, with intensity. I think it’s right that Carrick keeps the job until the end of the season and then hands the baton over to a Tuchel or an Ancelotti, someone of that world-class ilk.”
The appeal of Tuchel or Ancelotti rests on contrasting credentials. The draft noted both have Champions League success and could be available after the World Cup; the pair represent distinct managerial styles. Ancelotti has said: “There are two types of coaches: those who do nothing and those who do a lot of damage. I try to be in the first. The game is for the players and you can tell them a certain strategy but then the decisive thing is their quality and commitment.” The piece contrasted that view with Tuchel’s more interventionist reputation.
The article recalled Ole Gunnar Solskjær’s early caretaker surge: eight straight wins and a 74% win rate across 19 matches, including victories over Arsenal and Chelsea and that dramatic Champions League knockout of Paris Saint-Germain. His subsequent permanent record fell to a 52% win rate over 149 games and ended without a trophy.
Not all former players agree on Carrick. Roy Keane remained unconvinced: “Two great performances but anyone can win two games,” he said, and added, “If United win every game until the end of the season, I still wouldn’t be giving him the job,” and “I still wouldn’t be convinced he’s the man for the job. Absolutely not.
“They need a bigger and better manager. The size of the club and the challenges they face over the next few years, you want a manager who you feel can get them winning league titles.
“Are we going to sit here and believe Michael Carrick can get United winning league titles? It’s not enough for me. I don’t believe he is the man to get them winning league titles.”
Wayne Rooney backed Carrick strongly: “Of course he can,” and added, “I think Michael Carrick’s got an opportunity to show everyone, to show Manchester United, that he’s capable of doing that job.” “What we’ve seen is he’s very capable of doing it,” Rooney continued. “And if it continues like this, there’ll be a massive pressure on the Manchester United board to put him in at the end of the season.
“I know they’ve been there with Ole before, but I think this feels a little bit different.” Danny Murphy reacted with audible scepticism in studio, while Keane had previously questioned Carrick’s credentials, his backroom staff and even his wife before the Manchester derby. The piece also noted Ruben Amorim required 11 months to collect consecutive Premier League victories, a point Keane ignored in his criticism.
Carrick himself downplayed the speculation: “What happens next [manager position] I’m not going to be answering it every week,” he warned. “I’m enjoying it and I’ll continue to do what I can.
“I know from our perspective it’s just about moving forward to the next game. It’s been less than two weeks that we’ve been together, so it’s just keep getting good habits and good routines. The boys have been fantastic with that. ]
Manchester United
Carrick: Mainoo Freed from Amorim’s System and Seizing Midfield Opportunity
Carrick says Mainoo was pigeonholed under Amorim and now has fresh opportunities in midfield Update
Michael Carrick has publicly defended Kobbie Mainoo’s versatility and warned against simple labels after the midfielder’s limited role under Ruben Amorim. Carrick says the academy graduate had been unfairly narrowed into a single function, and the interim manager has adjusted the team shape to give Mainoo a fuller role.
“I like the way Kobbie takes the ball,” Carrick told Sky Sports . “I think that’s a big part of being a footballer, and being a top player is being able to cope with the environment.
“He’s come in at such a young age and played some big games in the Euros for England and for Manchester United and playing a big part in those games. So just being able to cope, first off, is a huge thing and he’s proved he can cope.
“He takes the ball, he drifts, he can play, he can play a little bit deeper at times, he can play a little bit higher up depending on who he’s playing with.
“I think sometimes we can pigeonhole players in certain things quite quickly and it’s not always the case. Sometimes you see things in a player and you tweak it a little bit, a bit like Patrick [Dorgu] playing a little bit higher. All of a sudden, things open up.
“Kobbie can play different roles within that, but definitely with Casemiro in the middle of the last couple of games we’ve had a really good pairing. They’ve been a big part of controlling the team.”
Amorim faced plenty of criticism during his time as United manager, primarily relating to his commitment to a 3-4-2-1 formation. Behind that, his use of Mainoo was the top concern among fans. Mainoo was limited by the reduced number of midfield places in that system and by Amorim’s view of him as emergency cover for Bruno Fernandes, who was given a deeper role.
Statistical record (all competitions): appearances 40; starts 16; goals 2; assists 2; total minutes 1,747; minutes per appearance 43.7.
Since Carrick replaced Amorim, Fernandes has been returned to a more attacking role in a 4-2-3-1 and a midfield pivot place has opened. Mainoo has taken that chance, earning two starts under Carrick and beginning to demonstrate the all-round role the manager described. The manager’s tactical adjustment has given Mainoo a clearer pathway to regular midfield responsibility.
Gameweek 24
Gameweek 24: Premier League predictions and short-form analysis
Predictions and brief analysis for Premier League Gameweek 24, focusing on key fixtures. Weekend 24.
After midweek’s conclusion of the Champions League and Europa League group stages, attention turns back to the Premier League for Gameweek 24. Manchester United arrive on Sunday buoyed by recent results under Michael Carrick, while rivals face a potentially decisive trip to north London for the title race.
Brighton and Everton meet in a tight mid-table duel where three points separate the clubs. Brighton’s reliable home record and Everton’s strong away form point to a close game. A draw looks the likeliest outcome: Brighton 1–1 Everton.
Arsenal travel to Elland Road under fresh scrutiny after their defeat to Man Utd. Mikel Arteta made sweeping changes in midweek and the side need points to rebuild momentum. Leeds’ strong run makes this a difficult test and a narrow win for the visitors is predicted: Leeds 1–2 Arsenal.
Wolves versus Bournemouth in the Midlands carries little immediate consequence for the table. Both defences have been vulnerable recently and an open, high-scoring game is probable: Wolves 3–3 Bournemouth.
Chelsea have enjoyed a marked improvement under Liam Rosenior, including a key midweek win in Naples. With Cole Palmer returning, Chelsea should have the depth to cope with a congested schedule and are favoured: Chelsea 3–1 West Ham.
Liverpool host Newcastle in an evening fixture that promises intensity despite midweek travel. Liverpool remain without a league victory in five games and Arne Slot’s side have defensive issues. Alexander Isak remains absent through injury. Expect a draw: Liverpool 2–2 Newcastle.
Aston Villa return to Villa Park while managing a mounting injury list in midfield and attack. They should just edge a competitive Brentford: Aston Villa 2–1 Brentford.
Man Utd will look to extend their run at Old Trafford against Fulham following consecutive big wins. United’s defensive reshuffle has steadied them and they are predicted to prevail: Man Utd 3–1 Fulham.
Palace continue a winless run of 11 matches with Oliver Glasner seeking to arrest the slide. Nottingham Forest arrive in better form and should take a narrow home victory: Nottingham Forest 1–0 Crystal Palace.
The weekend closes with Tottenham hosting Man City. City have regained momentum and, despite Tottenham’s ability to frustrate top sides, a Man City win is forecast: Tottenham 0–2 Man City.
Monday’s fixture sees Sunderland expected to overcome Burnley at the Stadium of Light: Sunderland 2–0 Burnley.
Fulham
Carrick urges caution as United prepare for Fulham test
Carrick warned United not to underestimate Fulham, insisting pragmatism can follow derby wins. Today
Michael Carrick insisted Manchester United must not take Fulham lightly, warning it would be “bang out of order” to do so while accepting his side may need to repeat the pragmatic gameplan that produced recent derby results.
United arrive at the match as clear favourites but Carrick was keen to temper expectation. “So it might be a case [that] it’s the same flow of the game as what we’ve had the last two weeks,” the reliably unflappable head coach shrugged. “No shame in that. We’ll deal with the game, what’s in front of us, and do whatever it takes for us to be able to come out on top.”
That approach was on show in the derby win over Manchester City, a victory that was only United’s second at Old Trafford since Halloween and one built on a surgical counter-attack through the middle. United recorded just 32% possession in that game, the fourth-smallest share of the ball recorded by the club in a home game over the past 20 years.
Fulham have proved difficult opponents for the division’s bigger teams. Under Silva they took four points from back-to-back fixtures against Liverpool and Chelsea in January and pushed Arsenal and, especially, Manchester City close in defeats earlier this year. Silva’s tactical tweaks were decisive in the 1–1 draw in August, when he explained: “We knew how they defend and we know they like to squeeze from the back five,” he revealed post-game. “And if you don’t give bodies for them to squeeze from the back five you can create superiority in the middle. We know they play with two in the middle, we tried to overload with our three plus Alex [Iwobi]. It was as simple as that.”
Carrick has reverted to a 4-2-3-1, bolstering the centre with Kobbie Mainoo alongside Casemiro, who both sweep up behind Bruno Fernandes. Fernandes’ return to the No. 10 role has been significant; he assisted goals against City and Arsenal. Silva’s side will look to exploit the space between the lines, with Bryan Mbeumo and Fernandes known to swap positions.
The squad’s mood has shifted under Carrick. Lisandro Martínez captured that change: “For me, when you touch my heart, I will give everything for you, and he touched it already and you can see that on the pitch we give everything,” and “You need people who understand your quality, and I think [Carrick] is doing that,” Martínez added. “He’s getting the best out of everybody, not just the players, but the staff. The standard, structure, and demands, are really important.”
Carrick has been emphatic about the emotional side of the job. “You’ve got to play with feeling. You got to play with emotion. You got to play with excitement,” he told assembled media on Friday. The manager will also be mindful of the early praise surrounding Ruben Amorim, who “hadn’t even taken charge of his first Manchester United game by the time players were already queuing up to laud his “top training sessions.””
