Man Utd
What Carrick’s Second Debut Revealed About United’s Immediate Prospects
Carrick’s second debut restored United’s speed, directness and balance; Mainoo and Mbeumo stood out.
Michael Carrick’s second, short-term return to the Manchester United dugout produced a display that suggested clearer identity and genuine momentum. The 2–0 scoreline in the derby flattered City; United had three goals ruled out for marginal offsides, Harry Maguire hit the bar, Amad Diallo struck the post and Gianluigi Donnarumma made a world-class save among several stops.
Carrick set up in a 4-2-3-1 that could shift into a 4-3-3 or even a 4-2-4, a flexible shape that emphasised speed, directness and intensity. Inside forwards were discarded; Patrick Dorgu and Amad were asked to play as true wingers, stretching the pitch, while Bruno Fernandes was given a No. 10 role with license to create. That approach produced several rapid counter-attacks, and it was one such break that led to Bryan Mbeumo opening the scoring after a period in which Donnarumma had kept City in the tie.
The return of Mbeumo and Amad from the Africa Cup of Nations clearly mattered. United’s goals per game had averaged 2.4 across nine fixtures before AFCON but dropped to 1.2 in the games following their departure, a run that included the FA Cup defeat to Brighton & Hove Albion. Carrick’s decision to use Mbeumo as a No. 9 rather than Benjamin Šeško allowed both Mbeumo and Amad to play in their best positions.
Kobbie Mainoo was handed his first full Premier League 90 minutes in eight months and delivered a composed, mature performance that justified the faith shown in him after Carrick’s public praise last summer on Rio Ferdinand’s YouTube channel.
Defensively, the return of Harry Maguire meant Carrick could select what was described as his strongest back four. Lisandro Martínez, when fully fit, again looked among the division’s top centre backs and won the physical duel with Erling Haaland. Diogo Dalot survived an early scare after a reckless challenge on Jérémy Doku. Fitness remains the major caveat if that back four is to build consistency.
Off the pitch, Roy Keane did not approve of Carrick’s appointment and suggested Sir Alex Ferguson lingers at Old Trafford like a “bad smell.” Keane also criticised the role reportedly played by Darren Fletcher, who allegedly sought ‘permission’ from Fergie before taking the short-term coaching role. Carrick’s immediate brief is straightforward: secure Champions League qualification with a top four or top five finish and bring consistency back to United’s season.
Man Utd
Carrick confirms Martínez will miss Bournemouth; hopes for Leeds return
Carrick: Martinez will miss Bournemouth but should be fit for the Leeds game after the break. please.
Michael Carrick has confirmed Lisandro Martínez will not be available for Manchester United’s trip to Bournemouth on Friday, but said the Argentina international is progressing and is expected to be ready following the international break. “He’s getting there,” Carrick admitted. “So after this one, I think he’ll be alright.”
Carrick also addressed the wider defensive injury picture, highlighting the ongoing problem with Matthijs de Ligt. The Dutch defender was first sidelined in November, and early tests suggested a short absence, but he has not been seen since and a return date remains unspecified. “It’s [a] similar [situation] really and frustrating for Matta,” Carrick continued. “He’s obviously trying to work to get back but it’s just the back issue, really, that’s proving difficult. We’ll keep working as hard as we can, to get him back as quickly as we can.”
With De Ligt still sidelined, Martínez’s likely comeback after the break is a tangible boost for a side with limited central defensive options. At present the senior choices named are Harry Maguire, Leny Yoro and 19-year-old Ayden Heaven.
The manager also offered an update on Mason Mount, who has faced repeated fitness problems since his move from Chelsea in 2023 in a package worth up to $75.7 million (£60 million). Mount has managed 66 appearances across all competitions for the club and has missed 58 matches through various fitness concerns. He returned to the bench as an unused substitute for the 3–1 win over Aston Villa at the weekend, and Carrick stressed caution over his reintroduction. “Starting would be too much, I think, at this point,” Carrick said of the midfielder.
Carrick’s remarks underline a careful approach to managing recovery across the squad as United prepare for a busy period that includes the visit of Leeds United on April 13 after the international break.
Man Utd
United Target Tonali as Casemiro Exit Forces Midfield Decision
United weigh Sandro Tonali as Casemiro replacement while Carrick rebuilds midfield urgently. transfer
Michael Carrick’s early impact has refocused Manchester United’s summer planning, and central midfield is a priority. United have collected 22 points from a possible 27 since Carrick took over from the sacked Ruben Amorim, yet Casemiro’s announced departure in the summer will leave a large gap to fill. The five-time Champions League winner has chosen to exit Old Trafford on his terms.
Linked names around Old Trafford include Elliot Anderson, Adam Wharton and Carlos Baleba, but increasing attention has fallen on Newcastle’s Sandro Tonali. The 25-year-old’s creativity, passing range and stamina are repeatedly cited, with his standout quality being the ability to perform those functions from a deep-lying playmaker role. Newcastle benefited from Tonali last term, reaching the Champions League round of 16 after a fifth-placed finish.
The i Paper report that Tonali has “rocketed” up United’s wishlist in recent weeks, a development fuelled in part by public signals from the player’s agent. Giuseppe Riso said: “If he shines at the World Cup, will City or Arsenal be hot on his heels? I don’t know … but it’s very likely. Everyone is waiting for the World Cup; then a thousand scenarios will unfold, but it all kicks off after the World Cup.” Riso named Arsenal and Manchester City in his comments.
Transfer context is congested. Anderson is reportedly on Manchester City’s radar and said to prefer the Etihad, while Adam Wharton is wanted by Liverpool. Brighton have maintained a £100 million ($133 million) valuation for Carlos Baleba, a price United were not prepared to meet last summer. Tonali would likely cost comparable sums, and Newcastle are unlikely to be forced into a sale at a reduced fee. He has more than three years remaining on his contract and Newcastle did not include a release clause when signing him from AC Milan.
United’s midfield blueprint must account for Bruno Fernandes’ attacking influence and Kobbie Mainoo’s potential, while replacing Casemiro’s presence. Recruitment this summer will be shaped by those realities and the scenarios Riso outlined, especially once the World Cup concludes. Italy, incidentally, are yet to qualify and must come through unscathed from the UEFA playoffs against Northern Ireland and one of Wales and Bosnia and Herzegovina.
Analytics & Stats
Opta Supercomputer Lays Out 2025–26 Premier League Forecast as Arsenal Lead the Way
Opta’s supercomputer predicts Arsenal favourites and projects points, qualification and relegations.
Opta’s supercomputer has produced a clear statistical view of the 2025–26 Premier League table, heavily favouring Arsenal while mapping out qualification and relegation probabilities. The model gives Arsenal 84.61 predicted points and a 97.46% chance of the title from their current 70 points. Manchester City sit on 61 points with a prediction of 74.70 and a 2.54% title chance.
The weekend’s results felt significant. Arsenal pulled further clear of Manchester City after a dramatic 2–0 victory over Everton inspired by the record-breaking feats of Max Dowman. City were held to a 1–1 draw against West Ham after Pep Guardiola warned that a slip up would be catastrophic. “Now it’s West Ham that defines the Premier League,” he declared. “Now we go there knowing that if we drop points, it will be over.” After the draw Guardiola insisted: “It’s not over.” The supercomputer remains unconvinced that City can close the gap.
Manchester United have opened up breathing room in the race for Champions League qualification. United sit on 54 points with a predicted 66.03 and a 78.07% chance of qualifying after a convincing 3–1 win over Aston Villa. “We are in a good position at the moment,” Michael Carrick admitted, “but still a lot to play for.”
The model projects Aston Villa, Liverpool and Chelsea to contest the remaining top-six positions, with Liverpool on 49 points and a predicted 61.80 (34.09% chance), and Chelsea on 48 points and a predicted 60.52 (23.21% chance). Dominik Szoboszlai captured the mood after Liverpool’s 1–1 draw with Tottenham: “We have to wake up because if we carry on like this, we should be happy with the Conference League.”
At the bottom, the supercomputer gives Burnley and Wolves near-certain relegation, while Leeds, Tottenham, Nottingham Forest and West Ham occupy the zone of greatest uncertainty. Tottenham headed into the weekend one point above the relegation zone and ended it level with Leeds, Forest and West Ham; the mood in north London has lifted after they ended their losing run.
The Opta projection frames the current landscape: Arsenal clear favourites, City still dangerous, United pushing for the top three, and a congested battle for European places and survival.
